On Monday Hermila García Quiñones, who on October 9th 2010 became the first female police chief of the city of Meoqui in Mexico, was shot and killed after leaving her home, which she shared with her parents, whom she supported, on her way to work. García Quiñones was one of four women who have recently taken on leadership roles in police departments in the Mexican state of Chihuahua, in the face of drug-related violence the government has been unable to control.
I wrote in October about the 20-year-old criminology student, Marisol Valles Garcia, who became chief of police in Praxedis G. Guerrero. Her youth and determination to prevent violence with “principles and values” rather than guns, were headline news for a brief moment, and quickly inspired two more women to become heads of security of their towns, also in the Juárez Valley – Verónica Ríos Ontiveros, of El Vergel and Olga Herrera Castillo, of Villa Luz. Both are small hamlets in Samalayuca, south of Juárez City, and since there are only a few officers and one patrol car, they will mostly take crime reports.
Although Hermila García Quiñones started before the other women, and led a much larger force of 90 officers, she didn’t receive quite as much publicity. She was unmarried and did not have children, and although criticized for her lack of experience in police work, she was at least an attorney and had worked in city government before. Her situation was similar to that of Silvia Molina, who in 2008 was the top administrative official of the police department in Ciudad Juarez and was also killed.
The media’s interest is greater for more exotic cases, the very young student with an infant, the two housewives she inspired. They would all seem to be part of the same trend, of women taking on security posts, and the death of García Quiñones, and Molina before her, make it doubtful that female gender provides any protection from the violence of the cartels. Maybe the other women’s inexperience and motherhood will make a difference, and maybe this is what they are hoping. So, this is just an update; if anyone has any thoughts, please do share
3 thoughts on “Follow up: women police chiefs in Mexico”
In contrast “Enforcement Takes On a Softer Side in China” http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/02/world/asia/02china.html?pagewanted=2&ref=world
“Four months after headlines around the world heralded her as the “bravest woman in Mexico,” Valles Garcia plotted a hasty escape across a remote border crossing in West Texas. Terrified of being tortured or killed, she fled the country without packing a suitcase. With her parents, sisters, husband and son, Valles Garcia crossed a footbridge into the United States and asked for asylum. “‘ came here for the security my country cannot provide for me …'”
“Maria Santos Gorrostieta: Mexico’s mayor-heroine found beaten to death. A mayor who became a heroine in Mexico after defiantly standing up to the country’s brutal drug lords has been found beaten to death after sacrificing herself to save her young daughter… “